Question 119 marks
Question
A student investigated the effect of temperature on the diffusion of vitamin C. Vitamin C is an important part of a balanced diet and is found in some fruits and vegetables. When vegetables are boiled in water the vitamin C diffuses out into the surrounding water. A dialysis tubing bag filled with vitamin C solution was used to represent a vegetable. The blue dye DCPIP was used as an indicator for the presence of vitamin C. High concentrations of vitamin C decolourise DCPIP quickly. The student used the method described in step 1 to step 14. Step 1 A syringe was used to fill a dialysis tubing bag with 10 cm3 of vitamin C solution. Step 2 The outside of the filled dialysis tubing bag was rinsed by dipping it into a beaker of distilled water. Step 3 A large test-tube was labelled hot. The dialysis tubing bag was put into the large test-tube and secured in place with an elastic band, as shown in Fig. 1.1. Step 4 Steps 1 to 3 were repeated with a second dialysis tubing bag and a large test-tube labelled cold. elastic band holding the open end of the dialysis tubing bag in place large test-tube dialysis tubing bag containing 10 cm3 of vitamin C solution Fig. 1.1 Step 5 The large test-tube labelled hot was half-filled with hot water. Step 6 The large test-tube labelled cold was half-filled with cold water. Step 7 The temperature of the water in the large test-tube labelled hot was measured. Step 8 The temperature of the water in the large test-tube labelled cold was measured. Fig. 1.2 shows the readings on the thermometer used in step 7 and step 8. 40 20 35 15 30 10 hot water cold water Fig. 1.2 (a) (i) State the temperatures of the hot water and the cold water shown on the thermometers in Fig. 1.2. Include the unit. temperature of the hot water …… temperature of the cold water …… [2] Step 9 The dialysis tubing bags were left in the large test-tubes for 15 minutes. Step 10 After 15 minutes, the dialysis tubing bags were removed from the large test-tubes and discarded. 1 cm3 of the liquid remaining in the large test-tube labelled hot was put into a clean standard test-tube. Step 11 A syringe was filled with 10 cm3 of DCPIP solution. Step 12 One drop of DCPIP was added to the liquid in the standard test-tube and swirled to mix. After a few seconds the blue colour disappeared. Step 13 The student continued to add drops of DCPIP until the blue colour remained after mixing. Step 14 Steps 10 to 13 were repeated with 1 cm3 of the liquid remaining in the test-tube labelled cold. The unused volumes of DCPIP remaining in the syringes are shown in Fig. 1.3. 10 10 9 9 8 8 7 7 6 6 5 5 4 4 3 DCPIP remaining 3 2 2 1 1 syringe used for the syringe used for the hot test-tube cold test-tube Fig. 1.3 (ii) Record the volumes of the DCPIP remaining in the syringes shown in Fig. 1.3. syringe used for the hot test-tube …… syringe used for the cold test-tube …… [1] (iii) Prepare a table to record the volume of DCPIP that has been used in each test-tube, in the space provided. Use your answer in 1(a)(ii) and the equation to calculate the volume of DCPIP that has been used in each test-tube: volume of DCPIP used = 10 – volume of DCPIP remaining in the syringe [3] (iv) State a conclusion for these results. …… [1] (v) Suggest why the dialysis tubing bag was rinsed in step 2. …… [1] (vi) Identify one source of error in step 5 or step 6 and suggest a suitable piece of equipment to overcome this error. error …… equipment …… [2] (vii) Identify the variable that the student changed (independent variable) and the variable that was measured (dependent variable) in this investigation. independent variable …… dependent variable …… [2] (viii) Suggest why repeating the procedure several times would improve the investigation. …… [1] (b) Dialysis tubing acts as a partially permeable membrane and can be used to represent a model cell to investigate osmosis. Plan an investigation to find out how different concentrations of sugar solutions affect the movement of water into or out of dialysis tubing. …… [6] [Total: 19]
Mark scheme
1(a)(i) (hot water) 38.5 and (cold water) 17(.0) ; 2 °C ; 1(a)(ii) (hot test-tube) 6.5 and (cold test-tube) 9(.0) ; 1 1(a)(iii) table drawn with a minimum of two columns and header line ; 3 headings including units ; data recorded as 3.5 and 1(.0) and hot / cold or stated temperatures ; ecf values from 1(a)(ii) 1(a)(iv) any one from: 1 (vitamin C) diffuses, more / faster, at high(er) temperature / in hot water ; greater volume of / greater amount of / more, DCPIP used, at high(er) temperature / in hot water ; 1(a)(v) to remove vitamin (C) (from the outside of the bag) / idea that 1 rinsing prevents contamination (by vitamin C) ; 1(a)(vi) error: volume was not measured ; 2 equipment: use a syringe / measuring cylinder / burette / graduated pipette ; OR error: temperature was not controlled ; equipment: use a thermostatically controlled water-bath ; 1(a)(vii) independent variable: temperature ; 2 dependent variable: volume of DCPIP ; 1(a)(viii) so that anomalous results can be, identifed / excluded ; 1 1(b) independent variable: 6 1 at least two concentrations of sugar solution ; dependent variable: 2 (measuring) mass / volume, before and mass / volume, after or change in, mass / volume (of dialysis tubing or test-tube) ; 3/4/5 variables kept constant, max. three from: volume of water (in dialysis tubing / test-tube) volume of sugar solution (in dialysis tubing / test-tube) temperature (soaking) time type of dialysis tubing / surface area of tubing type of sugar 6/7/8 method, max three from description of how to: make sugar solution, concentrations / dilutions maintain the temperature (during the investigation) make a model cell e.g., knotting dialysis tubing at both ends / other methods of securing dialysis tubing at both ends remove excess liquid from the tubing (if mass measured) measure, mass / volume / height, of water / sugar solution e.g., use of a balance / measuring cylinder / syringe / ruler 9 repeat the whole investigation at least twice more (three trials) ;