Question 121 marks
Question
A student investigated the effect of gibberellin (GA) and abscisic acid (ABA) on the germination of wheat grains. The student found out the following information. • The molecular mass of GA is 346 g. • The molecular mass of ABA is 264 g. • The range of concentrations at which GA is active in plant tissues is from 1 × 10−6 to 1 × 10−5 mol dm−3. • The range of concentrations at which ABA is active in plant tissues is from 1 × 10−6 to 1 × 10−4 mol dm−3. • Newly formed wheat grains contain a high concentration of ABA which decreases over time. • When the concentration of ABA falls low enough the GA is able to promote germination. • Wheat germinates best at temperatures from 10 °C to 25 °C and without light. Fig. 1.1 shows the germination and early growth of wheat. first leaf shoot young shoot young shoot visible beneath grain wall root hairs young root appears more roots appear roots germinated grain seedling at 7 days Fig. 1.1 To test the effects on germination of adding ABA, the student started by soaking wheat grains for 24 hours in a solution of 1 × 10−6 mol dm−3 GA. These were then split into several groups of 50 grains and a different concentration of ABA was added to each group. The student made a stock solution of ABA with a concentration of 1 × 10−3 mol dm−3 which was then diluted to make the solutions needed for the investigation. (a) (i) Using the information about ABA above, describe how the student made a stock solution of 1 × 10−3 mol dm−3 ABA. …… [2] (ii) The student used the stock solution of 1 × 10−3 mol dm−3 ABA to prepare a range of dilutions from 1 × 10–4 mol dm−3 to 1 × 10–7 mol dm−3 to use in their investigation. Each dilution had a volume of 100 cm3. Describe how the student prepared these dilutions. …… [2] (b) (i) Identify the independent and the dependent variables in this investigation. independent variable …… dependent variable …… [2] (ii) Describe a procedure that the student could use to complete the investigation to find the effect of different concentrations of ABA on the germination of wheat grains. Your method should be detailed enough for another person to use and should not repeat any details from (a)(ii) of how to dilute the stock solution. …… [5] (c) The student calculated the percentage germination of the grains in the different concentrations of ABA. (i) Explain how the percentage germination was calculated. …… [1] (ii) Complete Fig. 1.2 by sketching a graph to predict the results the student might expect. On the axes, show the range of values and the units that might be used to plot the graph. Fig. 1.2 [3] (d) In another investigation the student tested the effect of gibberellin (GA) on the elongation of shoots. Five groups of 20 wheat grains were soaked in GA solution. Each group was treated with a different concentration of GA and then left to germinate and grow for 10 days. The length of each shoot was measured and a mean shoot length was calculated for each GA concentration. Table 1.1 shows the results of this investigation. Table 1.1 concentration of GA / mol dm−3 0 1 × 10−7 1 × 10−6 1 × 10−5 1 × 10−4 mean shoot length / mm ± SE 120 ± 10 150 ± 5 175 ± 15 210 ± 12 180 ± 8 (i) Explain what standard error (SE) shows about the reliability of the results in Table 1.1. …… [2] The student carried out a number of t-tests. In each t-test, the student compared the mean shoot length of the seedlings grown from grains that were not treated with GA with those that were treated with GA. (ii) Suggest a null hypothesis for the t-test between no GA treatment and those treated with 1 × 10−5 mol dm−3 GA. …… [1] (iii) Explain how the student should use the values for t to determine if there is a significant difference between the mean shoot length of wheat grown with no GA treatment and the mean shoot length of wheat grown with GA treatment. …… [3] [Total: 21]
Mark scheme
1(a)(i) 1 distilled / deionised / pure / AW, water (as diluent) ; 2 2 (use) 0.264g ABA and (dissolve in) 1 dm3 water ; 1(a)(ii) 1 add, 10 cm3 of, stock solution / 1 × 10–3 (mol dm–3 ABA), to 90 cm3 (distilled) water (to make 1 × 10-4 mol dm–3 ABA) ; 2 2 description, of one correct subsequent step of the serial dilution ; 1(b)(i) independent variable: 2 concentration of ABA ; dependent variable: number of grains germinated or length of shoot ; 1(b)(ii) any five from: 5 1 (use of a control for one group of 50 grains) replace the ABA solution with, distilled / deionised / pure / AW, water ; 2 ref. to (placing wheat grains in a container with) soil / paper / AW ; 3 carry out experiment in the dark ; 4 method to maintain a, constant / stated, temperature (for germination) ; 5 ref. to adding the, same / stated, volume / mass, of water (to container of wheat grains) ; 6 for each ABA concentration, count / record / AW, the number of (wheat) grains that have germinated, after a, same / stated, time or for each ABA concentration, measure / record / AW, the length of the shoot, after a, same / stated, time ; 7 safety comment with hazard and risk and precaution ; hazard risk precaution wheat grains irritant / allergy gloves / mask / PPE ABA / GA irritant / allergy / toxic gloves / mask / PPE soil biohazard / pathogens / gloves / mask / PPE allergy / irritant 1(c)(i) number of germinated grains, divided by the, total number of grains, x 100 ; 1 1(c)(ii) 1 axes correctly orientated with labels and units ; 3 2 correct values on x-axis ; 3 line shows percentage germination decreases as ABA concentration increases ; 1(d)(i) any two from: 2 1 idea of smaller standard error (SE) shows that (the mean is) more reliable ; ora 2 idea of smaller SE shows that (calculated / sample) mean is closer to the, true / actual, mean ; ora 3 suitable example from Table 1.1 ; 4 correct ref. to overlap of SE from Table 1.1 ; for example: idea of, SE for 1 × 10–7 ABA concentration and 1 × 10–6 ABA concentration do not overlap, (therefore mean shoot length may be) significantly different or idea of, SE for 1 × 10–6 ABA concentration and 1 × 10–4 ABA concentration overlap, (therefore mean shoot length) is not significantly different 1(d)(ii) there is no difference, in the (mean) shoot length (of the seedlings grown from wheat grains with), no GA (treatment) and (1 1 × 10-5 mol dm–3) GA (treatment) ; 1(d)(iii) 1 use 38 degrees of freedom ; 3 2 compare (calculated) t-value with, critical (t-) value at, (p) = 0.05 / 5% ; 3 (if calculated) t-value is higher (than the critical t-value then) and reject null hypothesis / there is a significant difference ; ora