Question
Hanna buys 12 hollow chocolate eggs that each contain a sweet. The eggs look identical but Hanna knows that 3 contain a red sweet, 4 contain an orange sweet and 5 contain a yellow sweet. Each of Hanna’s three children in turn randomly chooses and eats one of the eggs, keeping the sweet it contained.
(a) Find the probability that all 3 eggs chosen contain the same colour sweet. [4]
(b) Find the probability that all 3 eggs chosen contain a yellow sweet, given that all three children have the same colour sweet. [2]
(c) Find the probability that at least one of Hanna’s three children chooses an egg that contains an orange sweet. [3]
Additional Page
If you use the following lined page to complete the answer(s) to any question(s), the question number(s) must be clearly shown.
Mark scheme
7(a) 5 4 3 60 1 M1 Either 12 × 11 × 10 in denominator
YYY: × × = ,
12 11 10 1320 22 or a × (a –1) × ( a – 2), a = 5, 4, 3 in numerator seen in at least
one expression.
4 3 2 24 1
OOO: × × = , A1 a a −1 a − 2
12 11 10 1320 55 One expression × × , a = 5, 4, 3 (consistent in
12 11 10
3 2 1 6 1 expression).
RRR: × × = , Correct order of values in the numerator is essential.
12 11 10 1320 220
M1 5 4 3 4 3 2 3 2 1
× × + × × + × × , either d = 11, e = 10 or
12 d e 12 d e 12 d e
d = 12, e = 12.
1 1 1
Condone + + OE
22 55 220
90 3 A1 0.06818. Dependent only upon the second M mark.
[Total =] , , 0.0682
1320 44
7(a) Alternative method for question 7(a)
5
C3 10 1 M1 Either 12 C3 in denominator or a C3 in numerator seen in at least
YYY: 12
= ,
C3 220 22 one expression.
4
C3 4 1
OOO: 12
= , A1 a
C
C3 220 55 One expression 12 3 a = 5, 4, 3
3
C3
C3 1
RRR: 12
=
C3 220 M1 5
C3 4
C3 3
C3
12
+ 12
+ 12
C3 C3 C3
1 1 1
Condone + + OE
22 55 220
90 3 A1 0.06818. Dependent only upon the second M mark.
[Total =] , , 0.0682
1320 44
4
7(b) 60 90 M1 60 1
[P(YYY | all same colour) =] ÷ their P ( YYY ) or or
1320 1320 1320 22
90 3
their 7 ( a ) or or
1320 44
2 A1 OE
, 0.667
3
2
7(c) In each method, the M mark requires the scenarios to be identifiable. This may be implied by a list of scenarios and then the calculations which will
be assumed to be in the same order.
A correct value/expression will be condoned as identifying the connected scenario.
Method 1
8 7 6 8
C 14 B1 8 7 6 8
C 336 56
[1 – no orange = ]1− × × or 1 − 12 3 = 1 − × × or 12 3 seen, condone or only, not
12 11 10 C3 55 12 11 10 C3 1320 220
OE.
M1 f g h
1− × ×
12 d e
Either d = 11, e = 10 or d = 12, e = 12
8
C
or 1 - 12 3 .
C3
14 41
Condone 1 − OE (not ).
55 55
41 A1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545
55 If M0 scored SC B1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545.
7(c) Method 2
4 3 2 4 5 4 B1 P(1 O)or P(2 O) correct, accept unsimplified.
12 × 11 × 10 + 12 × 11 × 10 + 672
P(1 O)= ×3 = M1 3 correct scenarios added, with at least one 3-term product of
4 5 3 1320
2× × × f g h
12 11 10 form × × seen, either d = 11, e = 10 or d = 12, e = 12.
12 d e
4 3 8 288
P(2O) = × × ×3 =
12 11 10 1320
24
P(3O) =
1320
984 41 A1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545
[Total =] = , 0.745 If M0 scored SC B1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545.
1320 55
Method 3
O Y R = 4 C1 × 5 C1 × 3 C1 = 60 B1 Number of ways either 1 or 2 orange sweets obtained correctly
(112 or 48). Accept unsimplified
O R R = 4 C1 × 3 C 2 = 12 Note 4C1 × 8C2 = 112 or 4C2 × 8C1 = 48 are correct alternatives.
4 5
O Y Y = C1 × C2 = 40
4 5 M1 3 correct scenarios (1, 2 or 3 orange sweets) added on
O O Y = C2 × C1 = 30
numerator, denominator 12 C3
O O R = 4 C2 × 3 C1 = 18
4
O O O = C3 =4
Total = 164
164
Prob = 12
C3
984 41 A1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545
= , 0.745 If M0 scored SC B1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545.
1320 55
7(c) Method 4
3 2 4 1 B1 17 17
P(R R O) = × × = P(R ^ ^) = or P(Y ^ ^) = . Accept unsimplified.
12 11 10 55 110 66
3 4 1
P(R O ) = × = M1 3 correct scenarios added, with at least one 3-term product of
12 11 11
3 5 4 1 f g h
P(R Y O) = × × = form × × seen, either d = 11, e = 10 or d = 12, e = 12.
12 11 10 22 12 d e
4 1
P(O )= =
12 3
5 3 4 1
P(Y R O) = × × =
12 11 10 22
5 4 5
P(Y O ) = × =
12 11 33
5 4 4 2
P(Y Y O) = × × =
12 11 10 33
984 41 A1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545
= , 0.745 If M0 scored SC B1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545.
1320 55
7(c) Method 5
4 1 B1 8 28
P(O )= = P(^ O ) = or P(^ ^ O) = . Accept unsimplified.
12 3 33 165
8 4 8
P(^ O ) = × = M1 3 correct scenarios added, with at least one 3-term product of
12 11 33
8 7 4 28 f g h
P(^ ^ O) = × × = form × × seen, either d = 11, e = 10 or d = 12, e = 12
12 11 10 165 12 d e
with correct numerator.
984 41 A1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545
= , 0.745 If M0 scored SC B1 0.745 ⩽ p ⩽ 0.74545.
1320 55
3