Question 121 marks
Question
Beetroot is a root vegetable that contains a red pigment in its cells. When beetroot is put in ethanol, the red pigment is released from the beetroot tissue and the ethanol changes to a red colour. You are provided with the materials shown in Table 1.1. Table 1.1 labelled contents hazard quantity B beetroot cylinders in distilled water none 2 A 100% ethanol flammable 100 cm3 W distilled water none 300 cm3 If any solution comes into contact with your skin, wash off immediately under cold water. It is recommended that you wear suitable eye protection. Beetroot tissue can stain clothing. You will investigate the effect of different concentrations of ethanol on the release of red pigment from beetroot tissue. You will need to: • prepare different concentrations of ethanol, A • put beetroot tissue into the different concentrations of ethanol • record the intensity of colour for each concentration of ethanol. You will make different concentrations of ethanol using proportional dilution of the 100% ethanol, A. Table 1.2 shows how to make up two of the concentrations of ethanol you will use. (a) (i) Complete Table 1.2 for the other concentrations you will use. Table 1.2 percentage concentration volume of A volume of W of ethanol / cm3 / cm3 100 20.0 0.0 0 0.0 20.0 [2] Carry out step 1 to step 14. 1. Prepare the concentrations of ethanol as shown in Table 1.2 in the beakers provided. 2. Label large test-tubes with the concentrations of ethanol stated in Table 1.2. 3. Put 10 cm3 of each concentration of ethanol into the appropriately labelled large test-tube. 4. Cut the beetroot cylinders into 2 mm thick discs using a single-edged blade. You will need 5 discs for each concentration of ethanol. 5. Put the discs into a small beaker and cover with W. 6. Stir with a glass rod. 7. Pour the liquid into the beaker labelled For waste. 8. Put the discs on a paper towel and blot them to remove excess W. 9. Put 5 discs into each of the large test-tubes. Leave for 5 minutes. While you are waiting use your time to continue with Question 1. 10. Label small test-tubes with the ethanol concentrations stated in Table 1.2. 11. After 5 minutes stir the contents of each large test-tube. 12. Pour the liquid from each large test-tube into the appropriately labelled small test-tube. Make sure that the discs remain in the large test-tubes. Fig. 1.1 shows the key you need to use to record your results. Key no colour very pale red (lowest intensity) deep red (highest intensity) Fig. 1.1 13. Observe the colour of the liquid in each small test-tube. It may help to observe the liquid with a piece of white card behind the test-tube. You may observe the same intensity in more than one test-tube. 14. Record your observations in (a)(ii) using the symbols shown in the key in Fig. 1.1. (ii) Prepare a table in the space below to record your observations. [5] (iii) State the independent variable in this investigation. …… [1] (iv) Use your results from (a)(ii) to explain the effect of different ethanol concentrations on the beetroot tissue. …… [3] (v) Identify two significant sources of error in your investigation. For each source of error, suggest an improvement. source of error 1 …… improvement 1 …… source of error 2 …… improvement 2 …… [4] (b) Scientists investigated the effect of water potential on the properties of potato tissue. This was done by placing potato cylinders in solutions with different water potentials for 20 hours. All other variables were kept constant. The tissue was then compressed. The scientists measured the sound that the potato tissue made as it was compressed using an acoustic emission meter. The measurement of acoustic emission from compressed potato tissue can be used to judge the quality of the potato. The results are shown in Table 1.3. Table 1.3 water potential acoustic emission / MPa / arbitrary units – 0.3 95 – 0.5 76 – 0.6 68 – 0.9 50 –1.2 43 –1.5 24 (i) Plot a graph of the data in Table 1.3 on the grid in Fig. 1.2. The position of zero on the x-axis is shown. Use a sharp pencil for drawing graphs. 0 Fig. 1.2 [4] (ii) Use your graph in (b)(i) to estimate the water potential of the potato tissue at an acoustic emission value of 80 arbitrary units. water potential = …… [1] (iii) Suggest how the scientists could make one improvement to the independent variable so that a more accurate estimate of the water potential at 80 arbitrary units can be obtained. …… [1] [Total: 21]
Mark scheme
1(a)(i) shows at least three more concentrations of ethanol ; 2 shows correct volumes of A and W to make these concentrations ; 1(a)(ii) 1. heading for independent variable: percentage concentration ethanol and before heading for dependent variable 5 and no units in body of table ; 2. heading dependent variable: symbol or colour intensity ; 3. readings for all samples ; 4. intensity of red colour decreases with decreasing concentration ; 5. results recorded using ++++ scale ; 1(a)(iii) identifies the independent variable as concentration of ethanol ; 1 1(a)(iv) any three from: 3 1. proteins in membrane denatured ; 2. dissolved phospholipids / hydrophobic components (of membrane) ; 3. increases permeability ; 4. higher concentrations of ethanol and more diffusion of pigment ; 1(a)(v) any two sources of error and improvements from: 4 1. colour judgement subjective ; 2. colorimeter or use of colour chart ; 3. cutting to 2 cm ; 4. use of cutting template or more precise method of cutting described ; 5. time lag ; 6. staggered start ; 7. washing only once ; 8. standardise, e.g. washing twice ; 1(b)(i) 1. x-axis: water potential / MPa 4 and y-axis: acoustic emission / arbitrary units ; 2. scale on x-axis: 0.25 MPa to 2 cm, labelled at least every 2 cm and scale on y-axis: 20 arbitrary units to 2 cm, labelled at least every 2 cm ; 3. correct plotting of all six points using small crosses or dots in circles ; 4. six plots joined with thin line passing through all points and line is either smooth curve or joined plot to plot ; 1(b)(ii) correct value from graph ; 1 1(b)(iii) any one from: 1 reduce gap between intervals ; AVP ;