Question
A set of friends consists of 7 men and 4 women. Three of the men are brothers: Ali, Ben and Charlie.
(a) Find the number of different arrangements of the 7 men in a line in which Ali and Ben do not stand next to each other. [3]
(b) Find the number of different arrangements of the 7 men and 4 women in a line in which all the men stand together and all the women stand together. [3]
(c) In how many ways can the 7 men and 4 women be divided into a group of 6, a group of 3 and a group of 2 if there are no restrictions? [2]
(d) The 7 men and 4 women are divided at random into a group of 6, a group of 3 and a group of 2.
Find the probability that Ali, Ben and Charlie are all in the same group. [4]
Additional page
If you use the following page to complete the answer to any question, the question number must be clearly shown.
Mark scheme
7(a) Method 1 Total – A and B together
7! – 6! ×2 M1 7! – k, k an integer ⩾ 1.
M1 m – 6! × n : n = 1, 2 where m an integer > 6!
n = 1 can be implied.
= 3600 A1
Method 2 Arrangements of 5 people then Ali and Ben placed
5! × 6 × 5 M1 5! × p where p an integer > 1.
M1 6×5
q × 6 × 5, q × 6C2, q × 6P2, q × , where q an integer > 1.
2
= 3600 A1
3
7(b) 7! × 4! × 2 M1 7! × r, where r is an integer, r > 1
or
4! × s, where s is an integer, s > 1.
M1 7! × 4! × t, where t is an integer, t ⩾ 1,
t = 1 can be implied.
241920 A1 CAO.
3
7(c) 11
C6 × 5C3 × [2C2] M1 11
Cv × 11-vCu × [11-v-uCw],
u, v, w = 6, 3, 2 u ≠ v ≠ w.
= 4620 A1
2
7(d) Method 1 Ali, Ben and Charlie must be in the group of 6 or the group of 3.
group of 6: 8
C3 × 5C3 × (2C2) = 560 B1 560 seen, accept un-simplified.
group of 3: 8
C6 ( × 2C2 × 3C3 ) = 28 B1 28 seen accept un-simplified.
560 + 28 M1 their ( 560 + 28) their ( 560 + 28 )
Probability they are in same group = or
4620 their (c) 4620
588 7 A1
= , , 0.127
4620 55
Method 2 Ali, Ben and Charlie must be in the group of 6 or the group of 3.
6 5 4 3 2 1 8 B1 4
Group of 6: × × × × × × C3 , 0.1212… seen, accept un-simplified.
11 10 9 8 7 6 33
1 4
= × 56 =
462 33
3 2 1 1 B1 1
Group of 3: × × = , 0.00606 ( 06) seen, accept un-simplified.
11 10 9 165 165
4 1 M1 4 1
Probability they are in same group = + their + their .
33 165 33 165
7 A1
= ,0.127
55
4