Question 119 marks
Question
You are going to investigate the reaction between two different solutions of aqueous sodium carbonate, labelled solution K and solution L, and dilute hydrochloric acid using two different indicators. Read all of the instructions carefully before starting the experiments. Instructions You are going to do two experiments. (a) Experiment 1 ● Rinse a burette with water and then with the dilute hydrochloric acid for Question 1. ● Fill the burette with the dilute hydrochloric acid. Run some of the dilute hydrochloric acid out of the burette so that the level of the dilute hydrochloric acid is on the burette scale. Record the burette reading in the table. ● Use a measuring cylinder to pour 25 cm3 of solution K into a conical flask. ● Add five drops of methyl orange indicator and five drops of thymolphthalein indicator to the conical flask. ● Stand the conical flask on a white tile. ● Slowly add dilute hydrochloric acid from the burette to the conical flask, while swirling the flask, until the solution becomes yellow. This is the first colour change. Record the burette reading in the table. ● Continue to add dilute hydrochloric acid from the burette to the conical flask, while swirling the flask, until the solution changes colour again. This is the second colour change. ● Record the burette reading in the table and complete the table. Experiment 1 burette reading at first colour change / cm3 final burette reading at second colour change / cm3 initial burette reading / cm3 volume of dilute hydrochloric acid added for first colour change / cm3 total volume of dilute hydrochloric acid added for second colour change / cm3 [3] (b) Experiment 2 ● Empty the conical flask and rinse it with distilled water. ● Repeat Experiment 1 using solution L instead of solution K. Experiment 2 burette reading at first colour change / cm3 final burette reading at second colour change / cm3 initial burette reading / cm3 volume of dilute hydrochloric acid added for first colour change / cm3 total volume of dilute hydrochloric acid added for second colour change / cm3 [3] (c) State the second colour change observed in the conical flask in both experiments. (d) For Experiment 1, compare the volume of dilute hydrochloric acid needed for the first colour change with the volume of dilute hydrochloric acid for the second colour change. …… [2] (e) Compare the concentration of solution K used in Experiment 1 to the concentration of solution L used in Experiment 2. Explain your answer. …… [3] (f) (i) Deduce the volume of dilute hydrochloric acid needed for the second colour change when Experiment 2 is repeated using 50 cm3 of solution L. . …… [2] (ii) State why using 50 cm3 of solution L would cause a problem. . …… . …… [1] (g) State the advantage of using a pipette instead of the measuring cylinder in these experiments. …… [1] (h) Explain why the conical flask was swirled as the dilute hydrochloric acid was added from the burette. …… [1] (i) At the start of Experiment 1, the burette was rinsed with water and then with dilute hydrochloric acid. At the start of Experiment 2, the conical flask was rinsed with water but not with solution L. (i) Explain why the conical flask was rinsed with water. . …… . …… [1] (ii) Explain why the conical flask was not rinsed with solution L in Experiment 2. . …… . …… [1] [Total: 19]
Mark scheme
1(a) three burette readings completed with initial reading < first end point and second end point and second end point > first end 1 point all five readings/volumes given to 1 dp or better and a consistent number of dp. 1 both titres correct based on readings 1 1(b) three burette readings completed with initial < first end point and second end point and second end point > first end point 1 both titres correct based on readings 1 first end point volume is comparable to supervisor 1 1(c) (from) yellow (to) orange 1 1(d) a greater volume is required to reach the second end point 1 (approximately) double 1 1(e) smaller volume (of acid) is required for K (experiment 1) OR larger volume (of acid) is required for L (experiment 2) 1 (so) L (experiment 2) is more concentrated than K (experiment 1) 1 OR (so) K (experiment 1) is less concentrated than L (experiment 2) answer is quantitative. Either L is 1.5 × concentration of K OR the volume of acid for L is 1.5 × the volume of acid for K 1 1(f)(i) numerical answer which is 2 × answer for second colour change in results table for experiment 2 1 cm3 1 1(f)(ii) more than can fit into burette 1 1(g) (more) accurate 1 1(h) to mix the solutions 1 1(i)(i) to clean / remove residues (of experiment 1 from the flask) 1 1(i)(ii) it would add an unknown volume of solution L 1