Question 119 marks
Question
You are going to investigate how the rate of reaction of magnesium ribbon with dilute acid changes as the concentration of the acid is changed. You will use five solutions of the same acid, A, B, C, D and E. Each solution has a different concentration. The acid is in excess in all experiments. Read all of the instructions carefully before starting the experiments. Instructions You are going to do five experiments. (a) Experiment 1 • Use the 50 cm3 measuring cylinder to pour 30 cm3 of acid A into the 100 cm3 conical flask. • Add a coil of magnesium ribbon to the acid in the conical flask and immediately start a stop‑watch. • Continually swirl the mixture in the conical flask until the magnesium ribbon disappears completely. Immediately stop the stop‑watch and record the time in seconds to the nearest second in Table 1.1. • Empty and rinse the conical flask with distilled water. Experiment 2 • Repeat Experiment 1 using 30 cm3 of acid B instead of acid A. Experiment 3 • Repeat Experiment 1 using 30 cm3 of acid C instead of acid A. Experiment 4 • Repeat Experiment 1 using 30 cm3 of acid D instead of acid A. Experiment 5 • Repeat Experiment 1 using 30 cm3 of acid E instead of acid A. Complete Table 1.1. Table 1.1 concentration of acid time for magnesium experiment acid in mol / dm3 to disappear in s 1 A 2.0 2 B 1.5 3 C 1.0 4 D 0.8 5 E 0.5 [4] (b) Write a suitable scale on the y‑axis and plot your results from Experiments 1 to 5 on Fig. 1.1. Draw a line of best fit. time for magnesium to disappear in s 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 concentration of acid in mol / dm3 Fig. 1.1 [4] (c) From your graph in Fig. 1.1, deduce the time for the magnesium to disappear when the concentration of the acid is 1.3 mol / dm3. Show clearly on Fig. 1.1 how you worked out your answer. time for magnesium to disappear = …… s [2] (d) The mean rate of reaction is calculated using the equation shown. length of magnesium ribbon in cm mean rate of reaction = time for magnesium to disappear in s The length of each coil of magnesium ribbon used in all five experiments was 5 cm. (i) Calculate the mean rate of reaction in Experiment 1. Give units for the rate you have calculated. mean rate of reaction = …… units …… [2] (ii) Deduce in which Experiment, 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5, the mean rate of reaction was the slowest. …… [1] (e) Explain why repeating each experiment is an improvement. …… [1] (f) (i) You are going to carry out an experiment to find the temperature change when the magnesium reacts with the acid. • Use the measuring cylinder to pour 30 cm3 of acid A into the 100 cm3 conical flask. • Measure the initial temperature of the acid in the conical flask. Record the initial temperature in Table 1.2. • Add a coil of magnesium ribbon to the acid in the conical flask. • Continually swirl the conical flask until the magnesium ribbon disappears completely. • Measure the final temperature of the acid in the conical flask. Record the final temperature in Table 1.2 and complete Table 1.2. Table 1.2 initial temperature final temperature temperature of acid / °C of acid / °C change / °C [2] (ii) Explain why controlling the temperature of the acid so that it remains constant is an improvement. …… [1] (iii) Explain why using a polystyrene cup instead of the 100 cm3 conical flask does not control the temperature of the acid. …… [1] (iv) Describe how the temperature of the acid can be controlled and kept constant. …… [1] [Total: 19]
Mark scheme
1(a) times recorded for all five experiments and times increase as table descended 1 all times recorded in whole numbers of seconds only 1 time for experiment 1 comparable to supervisor 1 time for experiment 1 half of experiments 3 1 1(b) y-axis scale is linear and points take up over half of space available 1 all points plotted correctly 2 best fit line 1 1(c) correct working shown at a concentration of 1.3 on graph 1 correct reading from their working shown on graph 1 1(d)(i) correct evaluation of: 5 ÷ time for Experiment 1 1 cm / s 1 1(d)(ii) Experiment 5 1 1(e) to check / verify / compare results / to get concordant results / 1 1(f)(i) temperature change calculated correctly and all temperatures and temperature change given to same number of dp 1 final temperature > initial temperature and temperature change comparable to supervisor 1 1(f)(ii) a change of temperature will change the rate of reaction 1 1(f)(iii) the polystyrene would prevent heat escaping 1 1(f)(iv) use a water bath (at room temperature / at starting temperature) 1